Quote:
|
Thank you for your reply. Yes, you are right, it falls under fiqh rather than Aqeedah. It seems you drifted the discussion to a rather different topic than the one we began with, and which is the title of this thread. You asked are they for a modern society, and the anwer is no. They can never procure modern arms and mostly hope that we go back to the medieval times so that they can display their valor on equal terms( which never happened for muslims).
|
Nope Ya Akhi, I was answering your questions one by one, and that was a must and Alhamdo Lilah we're finished with the previous points.
Now back to:
Quote:
|
You asked are they for a modern society, and the anwer is no.
|
I'm afraid you're wrong, because building and improving a civilization is not Black & White answer, but there are lots of factors and criteria taken to establish the basic infrastructure to start such a world wide Millennium project.
The first Factor is the peaceful Atmosphere.
I'm going with your flow and let's say I'm Ashabab leader and I've appointed you as my personal adviser, and I want to start developing the country, what would you suggest?
1- Dropping our weapons and start a scientific revolution and wait for the enemies to wipe us off the earth!
2- Submit my rendition to the west and live as a slave and allow them to build their bases on my land and allow them to spy on me and steal my resources in exchange for technology (i.e: South Korea, Iraq, KSA...etc)
3- Leave my country and live in the west to build their countries (i.e our scientists...etc)
I'm open to your options Akhi and I'm all ears?
Quote:
|
It also seems you dont know a lot about the youth movement.
|
Plz enlighten me bro?
Quote:
|
These guys have been there in one form or the other for the past 30 years but started using this name for the last 8 years.
|
I still remember the first video I watched them claiming their Name & Belief and I know about the Islamic Courts but here we have a different case just like what happened in Checheny and the nowadays Imarat claimed by Abu 'Uthman Omarov Dukku and in Afghanistan with Taliban and the rest of the chain, here is a link you can refer to bro:
Harakat al-Shabaab Mujahideen - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Quote:
|
You say it is okey not to open dialogue with people you dont agree with. I want the proof for that in the quran and sunnah.
|
Very easy Akhi:
قوله تعالى : { وإن جنحوا للسلم فاجنح لها وتوكل على الله إنه هو السميع العليم } .
فيها خمس مسائل :
المسألة الأولى : السلم : بفتح السين وكسرها وإسكان اللام ، وبفتح السين واللام ، وبزيادة الألف أيضا : هو الصلح ، وقد يكون السلام بالألف واللام من التسليم وقد تقدم .
المسألة الثانية : في ذلك ثلاثة أقوال :
الأول : أنها منسوخة بقوله : { فاقتلوا المشركين } ونحوه .
الثاني : إن دعوك إلى الصلح فأجبهم ; قاله ابن زيد والسدي .
الثالث : إن جنحوا إلى الإسلام فاجنح لها ; قاله ابن إسحاق .
قال مجاهد : وعنى به قريظة ; لأن الجزية تقبل منهم ، فأما المشركون فلا يقبل منهم شيء . [ ص: 427 ]
المسألة الثالثة : أما قول من قال : إنها منسوخة بقوله : { فاقتلوا المشركين } فدعوى ، فإن شروط النسخ معدومة فيها ، كما بيناه في موضعه .
وأما من قال : إن دعوك إلى الصلح فأجبهم فإن ذلك يختلف الجواب فيه ; وقد قال الله : { فلا تهنوا وتدعوا إلى السلم وأنتم الأعلون } .
فإذا كان المسلمون على عزة ، وفي قوة ومنعة ، ومقانب عديدة ، وعدة شديدة : فلا صلح حتى تطعن الخيل بالقنا ، وتضرب بالبيض الرقاق الجماجم ، وإن كان للمسلمين مصلحة في الصلح لانتفاع يجلب به ، أو ضر يندفع بسببه فلا بأس أن يبتدئ المسلمون به إذا احتاجوا إليه ، وأن يجيبوا إذا دعوا إليه وقد صالح النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم أهل خيبر على شروط نقضوها ، فنقض صلحهم ، وقد وادع الضمري ، وقد صالح أكيدر دومة ، وأهل نجران ، وقد هادن قريشا لعشرة أعوام حتى نقضوا عهده ، وما زالت الخلفاء والصحابة على هذه السبيل التي شرعناها سالكة ، وبالوجوه التي شرحناها عاملة .
As a result bring me an Islamic conditions to make such a truce convention and we'll speak again, I reduced all the proofs to this one for the sake of summarizing and remember this can be debated over the Puppet Gov not the UN or Ethiopians and I guess you know so or we'll take another direction in our talk here.
Quote:
|
I say wallahi they dont. They use rusty old mortars to bomb military bases in civilian areas FROM civilian areas, causing death by their stray hits AND the enemy's replies.
|
If so then this must be posted at their Forums to take care about the issue and I have to add also that people should not live in these areas, and I saw a video warning people to stay away from these places, so who we should blame here?
Again you have to ask them also if they're applying the Fatwah of Ibn Taymiyyah about Tatarrusse, this is another matter you should address.
Again you ask me questions that took us away from the main subject, anyway let's see your options from above.
Quote:
|
I ask God to lead them and us in the right path. Aaameen.
|
Ameen.